Sebastian Cerra v. R., Miscarriage of Justice

Click the link to meet Sebastian on Facebook: Free Sebastian Cerra
Contents contain links for easy navigation to evidence

Reference, No. 1;                    Application For Ministerial Review Miscarriage of Justice;
                                                 Tab, I, - IX, .......... 00001, - 00125

Table Of Contents;........................................................................................................................................................................................................ page, A, B

Tab, I.Application For Ministerial Review Miscarriages Of Justice;........................................................................................................ 00001, - 00004

Tab, II.Indictment Preliminary Inquiry;..................................................................................................................................................... 00005

Tab, III.Indictment Trial;............................................................................................................................................................................ 00006

Tab, IV.Decision Trial;............................................................................................................................................................................... 00007, - 00010

Tab, V. - VI. - VII.;     Appellants' Conviction Factum; and Respondents' Factum:.............................................................................................. 00011, - 00114

Tab, V. - VI. - VII,A Complete Understanding of The Entire History Central To The Appellants' Conviction Factum,
                                and the Respondents' Factum is Vital To This Miscarriage of Justice;........................................................................................ 00011, - 00014

       Mr. Glen Orris, Q.C., assessment of the Grounds For Appeal in the Appellants' Conviction Factum,
                                submitted and argued by: Mr. Klein and Mr. Foster, before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia;........................................ 00014a, - 00014f

Tab, V.Appellants' Conviction Factum By: Mr. Klein, M.; 2001, January, 03rd;....................................................................................... 00015, - 00052

Tab, VI.Appellants' Conviction Factum By: Mr. Foster, M.; 2002, August, 05th;....................................................................................... 00053, - 00090

Tab, VII.Respondents' Factum By: Ms. Rubin, W.; 2001, August, 07th;.................................................................................................... 00091, - 00114

Tab, VIII.Judgement Court Of Appeal For British Columbia; September, 13th, 2002;................................................................................ 00115, - 00123

Tab, IX.Judgement Supreme Court Of Canada; May, 20th, 2004;............................................................................................................ 00124, - 00125

Reference, No. 2, Part, 1;      Evidence In Support
                                                 Introduction, Page, A, - I; para., [1, - 626],
                                                 Page, 1, - 495; Appendices, No. 1, - 15.

Introduction; / Cerra v. R., Cover Letter; / Court Reporters' Article; / Attorneys' Statements;......................................................................... page, A, - I

Table of Contents;........................................................................................................................................................................................... page, 1, - 11

Overview of The Case;....................................................................................................................................................... para., [1, - 135]; - page, 12, - 48

Crowns' Case Pillar, 1;
Crime Scene Identification Evidence;............................................................................................................................. para., [136, - 305]; - page, 49, - 96

Crowns' Case Pillar, 2;
Crime Scene Vehicle Evidence;..................................................................................................................................... para., [306, - 427]; - page, 97, - 139

Crowns' Case Pillar, 3;
Crime Scene Injury Evidence;........................................................................................................................................ para., [428, - 480]; - page, 140, - 164b

Crowns' Case Pillar, 4;
Appellants' Post Offense Conduct;................................................................................................................................. para., [481, - 499]; - page, 165, - 178

The Case For The Appellant;...................................................................................................................................... para., [500, - 626]; - page, 179, - 238

Time Line Evidence;....................................................................................................................................................... para., [500, - 547]; - page, 179, - 204

DNA: / New Material / Non - Disclosure;........................................................................................................................ para., [548, - 583]; - page, 204, - 221

Reasonable Doubt; (Error) Charge To Jury;................................................................................................................... para., [581, - 583]; - page 220, - 221

What is Left Of The Crowns' Case;................................................................................................................................ para., [584, - 622]; - page, 222, - 237

Conclusion; To What Is Left of The Crowns' Case;.......................................................................................................... para., [623, - 626]; - page, 238

Appendix, 1; Arthur, C.;Fresh Exonerating Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;..................................................................... para., [627]; - page, 239, - 255

Appendix, 2; McMahon, M.;Fresh Exonerating Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;..................................................................... para., [628]; - page, 256, - 259

Appendix, 3; Sharp, G.W.;Fresh Evidence: / Multiple Suspects at The Crime Scene;....................................................... para., [629]; - page, 260, - 279

Appendix, 4; Kormendi, A.;Fresh Essential Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;.......................................................................... para., [630]; - page, 280, - 314

Appendix, 5; Reid, A.;Fresh Essential Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;.......................................................................... para., [631]; - page, 315, - 333

Appendix, 6; Orge, D.;Fresh Essential Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;.......................................................................... para., [632]; - page, 334, - 358

Appendix, 7; McCumber, M.;Fresh Essential Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;.......................................................................... para., [633]; - page, 359, - 372a

Appendix, 8; Seaton, A.;Fresh Evidence: / Possible Suspect: / Obstruction of Justice: / Non - Disclosure;................... para., [634]; - page, 373, - 380b

Appendix, 9; Gunderson, G.;Fresh Evidence: / Possible Suspect: / Obstruction of Justice: / Non - Disclosure;................... para., [635]; - page, 381, - 388

Appendix, 10; Boisselle, L.M.;Fresh Evidence: / Improperly Admitted Identification Evidence;............................................... para., [636]; - page, 389, - 419

Appendix, 11; Harris, J.A.;Fresh Evidence: / Improperly Admitted Identification Evidence: / Perjury;................................ para., [637]; - page, 420, - 460c

Appendix, 12;Fresh Evidence: / DNA Syringes: / Forensic Exhibits: / Non - Disclosure;................................ para., [638]; - page, 461, - 476

Appendix, 13;Fresh Evidence: / DNA, Forensic Laboratory Results: / Non - Disclosure;............................... para., [639]; - page, 477, - 486

Appendix, 14;Fresh Coroner Evidence: / Non - Disclosure;............................................................................ para., [640]; - page, 487, - 489

Appendix, 15;Fresh Crime Scene Exonerating Evidence: / Obstruction of Justice: / Non - Disclosure;......... para., [641]; - page, 490, - 495

Reference, No. 2, Part, 2;      Supplementary Supporting Evidence
                                                Tab, X., XI., XII.; Page, A00126, - 00281

Table Of Contents............................................................................................................................................................................................. A00126

     Tab, X.A.;      Fresh Evidence: / Non - Disclosure: / Late - Disclosure: /
                           Forensic Evidence Report: / Malicious Prosecution:............................................................................................................... 00126, - 00209

Tab, X.A.1, - Dueck, R.J.;.................................................................................................................................................................................. 00126, - 00163

Tab, X.A.2, - Wudrick, K.W.;.............................................................................................................................................................................. 00164, - 00182

Tab, X.A.3, - Gunderson, G.;............................................................................................................................................................................. 00183, - 00191

Tab, X.A.4, - Mellis, J.T.D.;................................................................................................................................................................................ 00192, - 00199

Tab, X.A.5, - Shaigec, G.J.;............................................................................................................................................................................... 00200, - 00209

     Tab, X.B.;      Fresh Evidence: / Non - Disclosure: /
                           Threats To Life and Assaults: / Regarding: The Victim and Other Suspects:........................................................................ 00210, - 00234

Tab, X.B.1, - Caldwell, P.;.................................................................................................................................................................................. 00210, - 00214

Tab, X.B.2, - Gladue, J.;.................................................................................................................................................................................... 00215, - 00216

Tab, X.B.3, - Bentley, V.;.................................................................................................................................................................................... 00217, - 00220

Tab, X.B.4, - Hazeldine, T. and Berkinshaw, B.;................................................................................................................................................ 00221, - 00222

Tab, X.B.5, - Hawrelak, S.;................................................................................................................................................................................ 00223, - 00232

Tab, X.B.6, - Hamerston, T.;.............................................................................................................................................................................. 00233, - 00234

     Tab, XI;      Unfair Trial Evidence On Behalf of The Trial Judge:
                        Fatally Prejudicial For The Proceedings and The Appellant:.................................................................................................... 00235, - 00258

Tab, XI; - Unfair Trial Evidence On Behalf of The Trial Judge: Fatally Prejudicial For The Proceedings and the Appellant;.......................... 00235, - 00258

     Tab, XII;     Fresh Evidence Confirms:
                        Mrs. Boisselle and Ms. Harris' Docket Identification Evidence of the Appellant
                        was Inadmissible and Improperly Admitted................................................................................................................................ 00259, - 00281

Tab, XII.A.; - Oral Rulings;............................................................................................................................................................................... 00259 - 00276

Tab, XII.B.; - Charge To Jury;.......................................................................................................................................................................... 00277, - 00281

Reference, No. 3;                    Preliminary Inquiry Transcripts;
                                                 1998, November, 16th, -to- 20th

Witness List

Barkman, B. P.; ................................................................................................................................................................................ day 5 / part 5; - page 62, - 93

Boisselle, L. M.; ............................................................................................................................................................................... day 1 / part 1; - page 69, - 94

Boisselle, E. R.; ............................................................................................................................................................................... day 1 / part 1; - page 45, - 69

Burpee, A.; ...................................................................................................................................................................................... day 3 / part 3; - page 39, - 60

Chrisholm, D. R.; ............................................................................................................................................................................. day 2 / part 2; - page 78, - 88

Cooper, R. J.; .................................................................................................................................................................................. day 2 / part 2; - page 37, - 40

Cunningham, G.; ............................................................................................................................................................................. day 3 / part 3; - page 86, - 101

Danilowich, C. J.; ............................................................................................................................................................................ day 1 / part 1; - page 98, - 103

Dueck, R. J.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... day 5 / part 5; - page 41, - 46

Ferrand, J. J.; ................................................................................................................................................................................. day 5 / part 5; - page 46, - 62

Filipchuk, D. C.; .............................................................................................................................................................................. day 5 / part 5; - page 93, - 114

Goldie, L. M.; .................................................................................................................................................................................. day 3 / part 3; - page 15, - 29

Gray, L. H.; ..................................................................................................................................................................................... day 2 / part 2; - page 40, - 78

Harris, J. A.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... day 4 / part 4; - page 72, - 106

Holmes, J. M.; ................................................................................................................................................................................ day 2 / part 2; - page 1, - 36

Holmes, K. V.; ................................................................................................................................................................................ day 3 / part 3; - page 1, - 14

Kroon, P. G. A.; .............................................................................................................................................................................. day 1 / part 1; - page 1, - 13

MacLean, C. D.; ............................................................................................................................................................................. day 5 / part 5; - page 32, - 41

MacPhearson C. J.; ....................................................................................................................................................................... day 1 / part 1; - page 103, - 112

Mazzega S.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... day 4 / part 4; - page 35, - 58

Merriwether, G. G.; ........................................................................................................................................................................ day 4 / part 4; - page 1, - 35

Prichard K. P.; ................................................................................................................................................................................ day 5 / part 5; - page 1, - 22

Rix, R. N.; ...................................................................................................................................................................................... day 1 / part 1; - page 13, - 45

Russell, G. W.; .............................................................................................................................................................................. day 5 / part 5; - page 22, - 32

Shaigec, G. J.; .............................................................................................................................................................................. day 4 / part 4; - page 58, - 71

Thorlakson, B. M.; ........................................................................................................................................................................ day 3 / part 3; - page 60, - 86

Whitfield, W. F. M.; ....................................................................................................................................................................... day 1 / part 1 - page 94, - 97

Woudstra, S.E.; ............................................................................................................................................................................ day 3 / part 3; - page 29, - 39

Reference, No. 4;                   Trial Transcripts;
                                                 1999, July, 26th, -to- August, 20th

Index

Volume I.; ..................................................................................................................................................................................... page 1, - 164

Volume II.; .................................................................................................................................................................................... page 165, - 348

Volume III.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... page 349, - 562

Volume IV.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... page 563, - 718

Volume V.; .................................................................................................................................................................................... page 719, - 897

Volume VI.; ................................................................................................................................................................................... page 898, - 1105

Volume VII.; .................................................................................................................................................................................. page 1106, - 1278